Elea, southern Italy, born c. 515 BC
Parmenides
Parmenides was the first philosopher to argue from pure reason to a conclusion about everything that exists, and the conclusion was astonishing: nothing ever changes, and there is only one thing.
The view
Parmenides wrote a single poem in hexameters, of which about 160 lines survive. A young man rides a chariot to the gates of Night and Day, where a goddess teaches him two ways. The Way of Truth sets out what reason shows. The Way of Opinion describes the world of the senses, in which, she warns, there is no true reliance.
The Way of Truth begins from a single thought: what is, is, and what is not cannot be. You cannot think or speak of what is not, because there is nothing there to think about. From that start the goddess derives, step by step, that what is cannot have come into being, since it would have had to come from what is not. It cannot perish, divide, move or change. It is one, continuous and complete.
It is all alike, and nowhere more or less, so that nothing holds it back from holding together; all of it is full of what is. Parmenides, B8, our translation
The argument
The strength of Parmenides' position is that he follows the argument wherever it goes, and refuses to let the senses overrule it. If change means that something that was not now is, and if what is not cannot be, then change is impossible. So the world we see, full of birth, motion and death, must be an appearance.
His pupil Zeno defended the conclusion with paradoxes: Achilles who can never overtake the tortoise, the arrow that cannot move in any instant. The time site follows Parmenides in that direction, towards a universe without flow. On this site the question is different: what is there? Parmenides' answer is the most economical ever given. One thing.
Where he meets Deutsch
Parmenides was the first to say that reality may be utterly unlike appearance, and that reason, not the senses, has the last word on it. Deutsch agrees on both counts. The table that looks solid is mostly empty; the photon that seems to take one path is accompanied by shadows; the universe we see is one layer of something far larger. No one could have found any of that by looking harder.
There is a second, subtler agreement. Parmenides' changeless whole is a block: nothing in it comes or goes. The multiverse of quantum theory, taken as a whole, evolves by a deterministic law, and in Deutsch's account of time nothing flows at all.
Where they part
For Parmenides reason works alone, deducing reality from an axiom about being. For Deutsch reason works by conjecture, and the world tests the conjectures. The shadow photons were not deduced from first principles. They were inferred, fallibly, from experiments whose results nobody expected.
And the conclusions point in opposite directions. Parmenides reduced reality to one undifferentiated thing. Deutsch's reality is vastly more various than it appears: more universes, more histories, and emergent things at every level from atoms to ideas, all of them real. Where Parmenides found appearances richer than reality, Deutsch finds reality richer than appearances.
| Parmenides | Deutsch | |
|---|---|---|
| What is ultimately real? | What is: one, whole, unchanging and unending, like a well-rounded sphere. | Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too. |
| How do we know what is real? | By reason alone. The senses deceive; argument shows what must be. | Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real. |
| One world or many? | One. Plurality is an illusion of the senses. | Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference. |
| Is reality independent of observers? | Yes. Being is what it is, whatever mortals believe. | Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws. |
Further reading
- Parmenides, fragments B1–B19, in Early Greek Philosophy, edited by André Laks and Glenn W. Most (Loeb, 2016), volume V.
- Karl Popper, The World of Parmenides (1998), essays on the poem and its place in the history of science.
- David Deutsch, The Fabric of Reality (1997), chapter 11, on time.
- Parmenides, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.