Views of reality
Thinkers
Each thinker has a page of their own: the view, the argument behind it, and where it meets and parts from Deutsch.
Each entry is marked by its answer to one question: is there one world, or many? Deutsch, following Everett, says many. Compare all views side by side →
Ancient
- Parmenidesborn c. 515 BCOne world
What is, is, and cannot not be. Change, motion and plurality are illusions of the senses.
- Democritusc. 460 – c. 370 BCMany worlds
Sweet and bitter, hot and cold exist by convention. In reality there are only atoms and the void.
- Platoc. 428–348 BCOne world
The senses show shadows on a cave wall. Reason turns round and sees the Forms that cast them.
- Aristotle384–322 BCOne world
The real things are individual substances, and change is the actualising of what was potential in them.
Early modern
- Galileo Galilei1564–1642One world
Shape, number and motion are in things. Colours, tastes and smells are only in us. Nature is written in mathematics.
- Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz1646–1716Qualified
Infinitely many worlds were possible, and God made the best of them actual. Its true substances are monads.
- George Berkeley1685–1753One world
To be is to be perceived. Matter is a needless hypothesis, and the world is ideas in minds.
- Immanuel Kant1724–1804One world
We know things only as they appear to us. The thing in itself lies beyond any possible experience.
Nineteenth and twentieth centuries
- Ernst Mach1838–1916One world
Science is an economical summary of sensations. Atoms are a useful fiction, not things anyone has seen.
- Albert Einstein1879–1955One world
The Moon is there when nobody looks. A theory that cannot say so is incomplete.
- Niels Bohr1885–1962One world
Complementarity: physics concerns what we can say about our experiments, not a reality behind them.
- Erwin Schrödinger1887–1961Qualified
Apply the wave equation to a cat in a box, and you get a cat both alive and dead. Something has gone wrong.
- Karl Popper1902–1994One world
Realism without certainty: three worlds, physical, mental and abstract, and propensities in place of collapse.
- John Archibald Wheeler1911–2008Qualified
It from bit: every physical thing derives from yes-or-no questions, and observers take part in making reality.
- David Bohm1917–1992One world
Particles always have positions, steered by a real guiding wave. No collapse, no special role for the observer, one world.
- John Stewart Bell1928–1990One world
No theory of local hidden variables can reproduce quantum mechanics, and experiment sides with quantum mechanics.
- Hugh Everett III1930–1982Many worlds
Drop the collapse. The wave function is all there is, and observers come to exist in many versions.
Contemporary
- Roger Penroseborn 1931One world
Gravity makes superpositions collapse, and mathematics is a timeless realm that minds can see into.
- Carlo Rovelliborn 1956Qualified
Properties exist only relative to other systems. The world is a web of interactions, not a collection of things.
- Max Tegmarkborn 1967Many worlds
Reality is a mathematical structure, and every mathematical structure exists.
- David WallacecontemporaryMany worlds
Everett's worlds are emergent, like tigers or tables: real patterns in the quantum state, picked out by decoherence.
- QBismfrom about 2002One world
A quantum state is an agent's degrees of belief about what they will experience, not a feature of the world.
- Nick Bostrom and Donald HoffmancontemporaryQualified
Perhaps we live in a simulation; perhaps perception hides reality completely. Two modern routes back into the cave.