Side by side

Compare all views

Every thinker on the site in one table: what is ultimately real, how we know it, whether there is one world or many, and whether reality is there when nobody looks.

Ancient (dates approximate) 500 BC 400 BC ParmenidesParmenides DemocritusDemocritus PlatoPlato AristotleAristotle Early modern 1600 1700 1800 GalileoGalileo LeibnizLeibniz BerkeleyBerkeley KantKant Since 1830 (dashed: living) 1850 1900 1950 2000 MachMach EinsteinEinstein BohrBohr SchrödingerSchrödinger PopperPopper WheelerWheeler BohmBohm BellBell EverettEverett PenrosePenrose DeutschDeutsch RovelliRovelli TegmarkTegmark
Lifespans, each linked to its page. Filled bars: many worlds. Open bars: one world. Tinted bars: a qualified answer. Parmenides' death date is a guess. David Wallace, the QBists, and Nick Bostrom and Donald Hoffman are in the table but not on the chart.

The four questions asked on every thinker page. Deutsch's answers stay in view for reference.
ThinkerWhat is ultimately real?How do we know what is real?One world or many?Is reality independent of observers?
DeutschWhatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too.Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real.Many worldsMany. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference.IndependentYes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws.
ParmenidesWhat is: one, whole, unchanging and unending, like a well-rounded sphere.By reason alone. The senses deceive; argument shows what must be.One worldOne. Plurality is an illusion of the senses.IndependentYes. Being is what it is, whatever mortals believe.
DemocritusAtoms and the void, and nothing else.By reason, starting from the senses but going beyond them. The senses alone give only bastard knowledge.Many worldsMany: countless worlds come into being and perish in the infinite void.IndependentYes. Atoms move as they must, whether or not anyone perceives them.
PlatoThe Forms: eternal, unchanging, perfect patterns, of which physical things are imperfect copies.By reason and dialectic, which recollect what the soul knew before birth. The senses give only opinion.One worldTwo realms, the visible and the intelligible, but one cosmos, made by a craftsman after the eternal model.IndependentYes. The Forms are what they are regardless of any mind.
AristotleIndividual substances, each a union of matter and form.From perception, by induction to first principles, then by demonstration.One worldOne cosmos, finite and eternal, with the Earth at its centre.IndependentYes. Substances exist and change whether or not they are known.
Galileo GalileiMatter with shape, size, number, position and motion. Colours, tastes and smells are in us.By experiment and mathematical reasoning together, not by authority.One worldOne world, though far larger and less special than Aristotle's.IndependentYes, for the primary qualities. The secondary qualities vanish without a perceiver.
Gottfried Wilhelm LeibnizMonads: simple, mind-like substances. Bodies are well-founded appearances of them.By reason, guided by the principles of contradiction and sufficient reason.QualifiedInfinitely many possible worlds, of which exactly one is actual.QualifiedQualified. Monads are real in themselves, but matter is how they appear.
George BerkeleyMinds and their ideas. There is no unperceived matter.By the senses, which give us ideas directly, and by reason about minds, including God's.One worldOne world of ideas, sustained by God's perceiving.Mind-dependentNo. To be is to be perceived, or to perceive.
Immanuel KantThings in themselves, which exist but cannot be known as they are.Through experience, structured by forms of intuition and categories the mind supplies.One worldOne world of appearances; whatever lies behind it cannot be counted.QualifiedQualified. Things in themselves are independent of us; the world as known is shaped by the mind.
Ernst MachElements: colours, sounds, pressures, spaces and times, neither mental nor physical.By observation alone. Theories are economical summaries of what has been observed.One worldOne world of experience. Talk of anything beyond it is metaphysics.Mind-dependentNo. The world is a complex of sensations; there is nothing behind them.
Albert EinsteinFields and their states in spacetime, existing independently of observation.By free conjecture, tested against experience. Concepts are inventions of the mind, not abstractions from data.One worldOne world. He hoped a deeper theory would restore definite properties to it.IndependentYes. A real external world is the presupposition of all physics.
Niels BohrThe question is ill-posed. Physics concerns phenomena: whole experimental arrangements and their results.Through experiments described in the language of classical physics; there is no other way to communicate results.One worldOne world of phenomena. Talk of what lies behind it is not physics.QualifiedQualified. Results are objective, but properties cannot be ascribed apart from the means of observing them.
Erwin SchrödingerWaves, he first hoped; later he came to doubt that the theory described reality as it stood.By physical theory tested by experiment, and with deep interest in Greek and Indian philosophy.QualifiedQualified. He thought one world; late in life he mused that every outcome might happen.IndependentYes. He rejected the idea that observation creates reality.
Karl PopperPhysical things, mental states and the objective contents of thought: three interacting worlds.By conjecture and refutation. Realism itself is a conjecture, the best we have.One worldOne world, open and indeterministic.IndependentYes. Realism is essential to science, and quantum mechanics does not refute it.
John Archibald WheelerInformation. Every physical thing derives its existence from the answers to yes-or-no questions.By acts of observation, which are also acts of participation.QualifiedQualified. He supported Everett's thesis, then withdrew his support.QualifiedQualified. No phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is an observed phenomenon.
David BohmParticles with definite positions, and a real wave function that guides them.By physical theory, which should give an objective account of individual processes.One worldOne world of particles, though the guiding wave carries every branch.IndependentYes. Particles have positions whether or not anyone measures them.
John Stewart BellHe wanted "beables": things that exist, rather than observables that are measured.By theory and experiment, without privileged observers. Measurement should not be a primitive.One worldOne world, he assumed, which forced the conclusion that nature is non-local.IndependentYes. He thought the role given to observers in quantum theory a scandal.
Hugh Everett IIIThe universal wave function, evolving deterministically, and nothing else.By taking the formalism of quantum mechanics seriously as a description of everything, observers included.Many worldsMany. Every outcome the equation allows occurs, each with its own observers.IndependentYes. Observers are physical systems described by the same equation as everything else.
Roger PenroseThree worlds: the physical, the mental and the Platonic world of mathematics, each emerging from another.By mathematical insight, which he argues goes beyond any computation, and by experiment.One worldOne world. Superpositions of large enough objects collapse objectively.IndependentYes. Collapse is a physical process, with or without an observer.
Carlo RovelliEvents: interactions between systems, and the relative facts they establish.By physics, which describes how systems affect one another, not how things are absolutely.QualifiedQualified. One world, but no single, absolute account of it.QualifiedQualified. No observers are special, but facts are relative to systems.
Max TegmarkMathematical structures. The physical world is one of them.By physics and mathematics, which discover the structure we are part of.Many worldsMany, at four levels, up to every possible mathematical structure.IndependentYes. The structure exists independently of anyone describing it.
David WallaceThe quantum state, and the emergent structures within it, worlds included.By our best physics, read literally, with emergent levels as real as fundamental ones.Many worldsMany: emergent, approximately independent worlds, picked out by decoherence.IndependentYes. The quantum state and its structures exist independently of observers.
QBismThe world exists and is creative, but quantum states are not part of it. They are agents' beliefs.Through each agent's experiences, the outcomes of their actions on the world.One worldOne world, which no single description captures from outside.QualifiedQualified. The world is real, but quantum states are personal to each agent.
Nick Bostrom and Donald HoffmanBostrom: possibly a computer running our world. Hoffman: conscious agents, of which spacetime and objects are icons.Bostrom: by probabilistic reasoning about civilisations. Hoffman: by evolutionary game theory, which says perception tracks fitness, not truth.QualifiedQualified. Possibly many simulations; possibly one reality behind many interfaces.QualifiedQualified. Something real exists, but it may be wholly unlike what we perceive.