Side by side
Compare all views
Every thinker on the site in one table: what is ultimately real, how we know it, whether there is one world or many, and whether reality is there when nobody looks.
| Thinker | What is ultimately real? | How do we know what is real? | One world or many? | Is reality independent of observers? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Deutsch | Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too. | Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real. | Many worldsMany. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference. | IndependentYes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws. |
| Parmenides | What is: one, whole, unchanging and unending, like a well-rounded sphere. | By reason alone. The senses deceive; argument shows what must be. | One worldOne. Plurality is an illusion of the senses. | IndependentYes. Being is what it is, whatever mortals believe. |
| Democritus | Atoms and the void, and nothing else. | By reason, starting from the senses but going beyond them. The senses alone give only bastard knowledge. | Many worldsMany: countless worlds come into being and perish in the infinite void. | IndependentYes. Atoms move as they must, whether or not anyone perceives them. |
| Plato | The Forms: eternal, unchanging, perfect patterns, of which physical things are imperfect copies. | By reason and dialectic, which recollect what the soul knew before birth. The senses give only opinion. | One worldTwo realms, the visible and the intelligible, but one cosmos, made by a craftsman after the eternal model. | IndependentYes. The Forms are what they are regardless of any mind. |
| Aristotle | Individual substances, each a union of matter and form. | From perception, by induction to first principles, then by demonstration. | One worldOne cosmos, finite and eternal, with the Earth at its centre. | IndependentYes. Substances exist and change whether or not they are known. |
| Galileo Galilei | Matter with shape, size, number, position and motion. Colours, tastes and smells are in us. | By experiment and mathematical reasoning together, not by authority. | One worldOne world, though far larger and less special than Aristotle's. | IndependentYes, for the primary qualities. The secondary qualities vanish without a perceiver. |
| Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz | Monads: simple, mind-like substances. Bodies are well-founded appearances of them. | By reason, guided by the principles of contradiction and sufficient reason. | QualifiedInfinitely many possible worlds, of which exactly one is actual. | QualifiedQualified. Monads are real in themselves, but matter is how they appear. |
| George Berkeley | Minds and their ideas. There is no unperceived matter. | By the senses, which give us ideas directly, and by reason about minds, including God's. | One worldOne world of ideas, sustained by God's perceiving. | Mind-dependentNo. To be is to be perceived, or to perceive. |
| Immanuel Kant | Things in themselves, which exist but cannot be known as they are. | Through experience, structured by forms of intuition and categories the mind supplies. | One worldOne world of appearances; whatever lies behind it cannot be counted. | QualifiedQualified. Things in themselves are independent of us; the world as known is shaped by the mind. |
| Ernst Mach | Elements: colours, sounds, pressures, spaces and times, neither mental nor physical. | By observation alone. Theories are economical summaries of what has been observed. | One worldOne world of experience. Talk of anything beyond it is metaphysics. | Mind-dependentNo. The world is a complex of sensations; there is nothing behind them. |
| Albert Einstein | Fields and their states in spacetime, existing independently of observation. | By free conjecture, tested against experience. Concepts are inventions of the mind, not abstractions from data. | One worldOne world. He hoped a deeper theory would restore definite properties to it. | IndependentYes. A real external world is the presupposition of all physics. |
| Niels Bohr | The question is ill-posed. Physics concerns phenomena: whole experimental arrangements and their results. | Through experiments described in the language of classical physics; there is no other way to communicate results. | One worldOne world of phenomena. Talk of what lies behind it is not physics. | QualifiedQualified. Results are objective, but properties cannot be ascribed apart from the means of observing them. |
| Erwin Schrödinger | Waves, he first hoped; later he came to doubt that the theory described reality as it stood. | By physical theory tested by experiment, and with deep interest in Greek and Indian philosophy. | QualifiedQualified. He thought one world; late in life he mused that every outcome might happen. | IndependentYes. He rejected the idea that observation creates reality. |
| Karl Popper | Physical things, mental states and the objective contents of thought: three interacting worlds. | By conjecture and refutation. Realism itself is a conjecture, the best we have. | One worldOne world, open and indeterministic. | IndependentYes. Realism is essential to science, and quantum mechanics does not refute it. |
| John Archibald Wheeler | Information. Every physical thing derives its existence from the answers to yes-or-no questions. | By acts of observation, which are also acts of participation. | QualifiedQualified. He supported Everett's thesis, then withdrew his support. | QualifiedQualified. No phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is an observed phenomenon. |
| David Bohm | Particles with definite positions, and a real wave function that guides them. | By physical theory, which should give an objective account of individual processes. | One worldOne world of particles, though the guiding wave carries every branch. | IndependentYes. Particles have positions whether or not anyone measures them. |
| John Stewart Bell | He wanted "beables": things that exist, rather than observables that are measured. | By theory and experiment, without privileged observers. Measurement should not be a primitive. | One worldOne world, he assumed, which forced the conclusion that nature is non-local. | IndependentYes. He thought the role given to observers in quantum theory a scandal. |
| Hugh Everett III | The universal wave function, evolving deterministically, and nothing else. | By taking the formalism of quantum mechanics seriously as a description of everything, observers included. | Many worldsMany. Every outcome the equation allows occurs, each with its own observers. | IndependentYes. Observers are physical systems described by the same equation as everything else. |
| Roger Penrose | Three worlds: the physical, the mental and the Platonic world of mathematics, each emerging from another. | By mathematical insight, which he argues goes beyond any computation, and by experiment. | One worldOne world. Superpositions of large enough objects collapse objectively. | IndependentYes. Collapse is a physical process, with or without an observer. |
| Carlo Rovelli | Events: interactions between systems, and the relative facts they establish. | By physics, which describes how systems affect one another, not how things are absolutely. | QualifiedQualified. One world, but no single, absolute account of it. | QualifiedQualified. No observers are special, but facts are relative to systems. |
| Max Tegmark | Mathematical structures. The physical world is one of them. | By physics and mathematics, which discover the structure we are part of. | Many worldsMany, at four levels, up to every possible mathematical structure. | IndependentYes. The structure exists independently of anyone describing it. |
| David Wallace | The quantum state, and the emergent structures within it, worlds included. | By our best physics, read literally, with emergent levels as real as fundamental ones. | Many worldsMany: emergent, approximately independent worlds, picked out by decoherence. | IndependentYes. The quantum state and its structures exist independently of observers. |
| QBism | The world exists and is creative, but quantum states are not part of it. They are agents' beliefs. | Through each agent's experiences, the outcomes of their actions on the world. | One worldOne world, which no single description captures from outside. | QualifiedQualified. The world is real, but quantum states are personal to each agent. |
| Nick Bostrom and Donald Hoffman | Bostrom: possibly a computer running our world. Hoffman: conscious agents, of which spacetime and objects are icons. | Bostrom: by probabilistic reasoning about civilisations. Hoffman: by evolutionary game theory, which says perception tracks fitness, not truth. | QualifiedQualified. Possibly many simulations; possibly one reality behind many interfaces. | QualifiedQualified. Something real exists, but it may be wholly unlike what we perceive. |