Abdera, Thrace, c. 460 – c. 370 BC

Democritus

Democritus answered Parmenides with the boldest conjecture of the ancient world. Reality is made of tiny indivisible bodies, too small to see, moving through empty space. Everything else is appearance.

A laughing old man with a grey beard, in a dark cloak and hat, points to a globe beside him
Hendrick ter Brugghen, Democritus, 1628. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam. Later legend made him the laughing philosopher, amused by human folly, beside a globe of the world his atoms made.Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The view

Leucippus first proposed it, and his pupil Democritus worked it out in dozens of books, all lost. What survives comes through quotations and the reports of Aristotle and others. The core is clear. Parmenides had argued that change needs what is not, and that what is not cannot be. Democritus accepted the first premise and denied the second. What is not is the void, empty space, and it is as real as what fills it.

What fills it is atoms: solid, indivisible, eternal, differing only in shape, arrangement and position. They move through the void, collide, hook together and come apart. Every object we see, every change we notice, is a rearrangement of them. Nothing comes from nothing and nothing perishes into nothing, just as Parmenides said; things only change their arrangement.

By convention sweet, by convention bitter, by convention hot, by convention cold, by convention colour; in reality atoms and void. Democritus, B9, our translation

The argument

The senses tell us that honey is sweet. But the same honey tastes bitter to someone with a fever, and what is warm to one hand is cool to the other. So sweetness is not in the honey. It arises when atoms of a certain shape meet the atoms of the tongue. What the honey really has is atoms of a certain size and shape; sweetness is what that structure does to us.

Democritus saw the cost. In a famous fragment the senses reply to reason: you take your evidence from us and then you overthrow us, and our fall is yours. He did not pretend the problem away. Reason starts from appearances and goes beyond them, and if it ever forgets where it started it has no way to check itself.

A drop of honey, golden and sweet: how it appears.

Where he meets Deutsch

This is the template for every realist theory since. Democritus explained what we see by something we cannot see, and he was right that the invisible thing was real. It took more than two thousand years, and atoms were still dismissed as a useful fiction by Ernst Mach in the 1890s. Deutsch's criterion of reality would have settled the matter long before: if atoms are needed to explain what we observe, they exist.

The atomists also believed in countless worlds, coming into being and passing away throughout an infinite void. Their worlds were not Everett's, but the instinct is the same: there is no reason for reality to stop where our view of it stops.

Where they part

Democritus was a reductionist. Only atoms and the void are real; everything else, including colours, tastes, statues and people, is a convention, a way the atoms strike us. Deutsch's criterion makes no such cut. A statue of Churchill is as real as its copper, because the explanation of why the copper is there runs through the statue and not the other way round. Emergent things are not conventions. They are where many of the true explanations are.

And the atoms themselves turned out to be neither indivisible nor alone. Quantum theory dissolved them into fields and amplitudes spread across the multiverse. Democritus's method won; his particular conjecture, like every conjecture, was improved on.

Democritus and Deutsch side by side
DemocritusDeutsch
What is ultimately real?Atoms and the void, and nothing else.Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too.
How do we know what is real?By reason, starting from the senses but going beyond them. The senses alone give only bastard knowledge.Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real.
One world or many?Many: countless worlds come into being and perish in the infinite void.Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference.
Is reality independent of observers?Yes. Atoms move as they must, whether or not anyone perceives them.Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws.

See every view compared →

Further reading