Stagira and Athens, 384–322 BC
Aristotle
Aristotle brought reality back down to earth. The real things are not Forms in another realm but this horse and this man. And change is no illusion: it is what was possible in a thing becoming actual.
The view
Aristotle studied with Plato for twenty years and came to reject his central doctrine. A Form separated from the things that have it explains nothing, he argued: it neither makes them what they are nor tells us how they change. The primary realities, the things that exist in the fullest sense, are individual substances. Socrates is a substance; his paleness is not, because it exists only in him.
Each substance is a compound of matter and form. The bronze of a statue is its matter; its shape is its form. In a living thing the form is the soul, the organisation that makes the matter alive. Forms are real, but only in things.
Being is said in many ways, but all of them in relation to one starting point. Aristotle, Metaphysics Γ.2, our translation
The argument
Parmenides had said change was impossible, because it would need something to come from nothing. Aristotle's answer was to distinguish two ways of being. An acorn is not an oak, but it is not simply nothing-oak either: it is an oak potentially. Change is the actualising of a potential. Nothing comes from what is not without qualification; it comes from what is potentially.
This gave him four kinds of explanation for anything: what it is made of, what form it has, what brought it about, and what it is for. A full understanding of a thing answers all four.
Where he meets Deutsch
Aristotle's realism is Deutsch's in outline. The world exists independently of us; it is made of many kinds of thing at many levels; and the aim of inquiry is explanation, not mere description. His insistence that a form or organisation is real, though not a separate object, anticipates Deutsch's defence of emergent things.
The potential and the actual have also returned to the foundations of physics. Constructor theory, which Deutsch develops with Chiara Marletto, states the laws of physics as claims about which transformations are possible and which are impossible. Possibility is no longer a shadow of actuality. It is part of what the laws describe.
Where they part
Aristotle's physics trusted common sense where it should have been overturned. He denied the void and the atom, put the Earth at the centre of a finite cosmos, and explained motion by the natural places of the elements. For eighteen centuries his authority made those errors hard to correct, which is why Deutsch counts the medieval reverence for Aristotle as an example of how knowledge stops growing.
And his potentials are directed: an acorn is for the sake of the oak. Constructor theory's possibilities have no purposes. Whether a transformation is possible is a fact about the laws of physics, not about what a thing is striving to become.
| Aristotle | Deutsch | |
|---|---|---|
| What is ultimately real? | Individual substances, each a union of matter and form. | Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too. |
| How do we know what is real? | From perception, by induction to first principles, then by demonstration. | Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real. |
| One world or many? | One cosmos, finite and eternal, with the Earth at its centre. | Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference. |
| Is reality independent of observers? | Yes. Substances exist and change whether or not they are known. | Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws. |
Further reading
- Aristotle, Categories 1–5 and Metaphysics books Z and Θ, on substance and potentiality.
- Aristotle, Physics II, on the four kinds of cause.
- Chiara Marletto, The Science of Can and Can't (2021).
- Aristotle's Metaphysics, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.