Copenhagen, 1885–1962
Niels Bohr
Niels Bohr built the first quantum model of the atom and then spent decades explaining why nobody should ask what an atom is like when unobserved. His answer, complementarity, became the orthodox philosophy of quantum mechanics.
The view
In September 1927, at a conference at Como, Bohr introduced the idea he would refine for the rest of his life. Light and matter behave sometimes like waves and sometimes like particles. The two descriptions contradict each other, and yet both are needed. Bohr's resolution was that they are never needed at the same time. An experiment that reveals wave behaviour, such as interference, rules out one that reveals which path a particle took, and the other way round. The two descriptions are complementary: mutually exclusive, jointly necessary.
What, then, is an electron really, between measurements? Bohr's answer was that the question has no meaning. A phenomenon is the whole experimental arrangement together with its result, and the arrangement must be described in ordinary classical terms, or the result cannot be communicated. There is no further fact about the electron on its own.
After Bohr: it is wrong to think that the task of physics is to find out how nature is. Physics concerns what we can say about nature.
The argument
Bohr's debates with Einstein, at the Solvay conferences of 1927 and 1930, are among the most famous in science. Einstein proposed thought experiments to beat the uncertainty principle, measuring both the path of a particle and the interference it produced. Each time Bohr found the flaw, once by using Einstein's own general relativity. When Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen argued in 1935 that quantum mechanics was incomplete, Bohr replied that their "element of reality" could not be defined independently of the whole experimental arrangement.
Where he meets Deutsch
Bohr was right about the experiments. Recording which path a particle takes does destroy the interference, and the formalism he helped build predicts every result correctly. Deutsch accepts all of that. In the multiverse account, the which-path record makes the instances of the particle different from one another, so they can no longer interfere, which is the same prediction with an explanation attached.
Where they part
Deutsch regards Bohr's philosophy as the most damaging example of instrumentalism in modern science. It took the most successful theory ever devised and declared that it was not about anything. Generations of physicists were taught that asking what happens between measurements was naive, and the question of what quantum mechanics says about reality was pushed out of physics for half a century. Everett's thesis, which answered it, was ignored.
Complementarity also explains nothing. Saying that two descriptions are mutually exclusive but both necessary is a description of the puzzle, not its solution. And it leaves the observer outside physics, described in classical terms by fiat, though the observer is made of the same atoms as everything else. Everett's move was to put the observer back in.
| Bohr | Deutsch | |
|---|---|---|
| What is ultimately real? | The question is ill-posed. Physics concerns phenomena: whole experimental arrangements and their results. | Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too. |
| How do we know what is real? | Through experiments described in the language of classical physics; there is no other way to communicate results. | Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real. |
| One world or many? | One world of phenomena. Talk of what lies behind it is not physics. | Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference. |
| Is reality independent of observers? | Qualified. Results are objective, but properties cannot be ascribed apart from the means of observing them. | Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws. |
Further reading
- Niels Bohr, "Discussion with Einstein on epistemological problems in atomic physics" (1949), in Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist, edited by P. A. Schilpp.
- Adam Becker, What Is Real? The Unfinished Quest for the Meaning of Quantum Physics (2018), a history critical of Copenhagen.
- David Deutsch, The Beginning of Infinity (2011), chapter 12.
- Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.