Vienna, Zurich, Berlin, Dublin, 1887–1961
Erwin Schrödinger
Schrödinger wrote down the equation at the heart of quantum mechanics, and then imagined a cat in a box to show what it implies if you take it seriously all the way up. He meant it as a reductio. Everett took it literally.
The view
In 1926 Schrödinger published the wave equation that describes how a quantum system evolves. He hoped at first that the waves were real, smeared-out matter, and that the jumps and particles of Bohr's atom could be done away with. That hope failed: the wave function for two particles lives not in ordinary space but in a space of many dimensions, and individual detections are always sharp, never smeared.
The orthodox answer was that the wave function collapses when a measurement is made. Schrödinger thought this was a fudge. In a long paper of 1935, written in the wake of the EPR argument, he described what happens if you follow the equation from the atom up to the everyday world.
After Schrödinger (1935): one can even set up quite burlesque cases, such as a cat penned up in a steel chamber.
The argument
Put a cat in a sealed box with a small amount of radioactive substance, a Geiger counter and a flask of poison. If an atom decays within the hour, the counter fires and the flask is broken. The equation, applied to the whole box, says that after an hour the state is a superposition: a living cat and a dead cat, mixed, as Schrödinger put it, in equal parts. Nobody believes that about a cat. So something must be wrong with the theory, or with the way it was being applied, between the atom and the cat.
He coined the word "entanglement" in the same year, for the way two systems that have interacted can no longer be described separately. He saw it as the characteristic trait of quantum mechanics.
Where he meets Deutsch
Schrödinger refused to treat the equation as a mere calculating device that works for atoms and stops working for cats. If the theory is true, it applies to everything, boxes and observers included. That is Everett's premise and Deutsch's. The cat is not an argument against applying quantum mechanics to large things. It is the clearest statement of what applying it means.
In a lecture in Dublin in 1952, Schrödinger himself floated the idea that the alternatives in the equation might not be alternatives but all really happen simultaneously. He did not develop it. Everett, five years later, did.
Where they part
Schrödinger drew the wrong lesson from the cat, at least at first. He took the superposition of a live and dead cat as absurd, and so as evidence that the theory was incomplete. Everett's answer was that there is no absurdity, because there is no single cat in a blurred state. There are two sets of instances: in one, the cat is alive and so is everyone who looks; in the other, the cat is dead. Each observer sees a definite outcome, exactly as experience requires. The equation was right all along.
| Schrödinger | Deutsch | |
|---|---|---|
| What is ultimately real? | Waves, he first hoped; later he came to doubt that the theory described reality as it stood. | Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too. |
| How do we know what is real? | By physical theory tested by experiment, and with deep interest in Greek and Indian philosophy. | Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real. |
| One world or many? | Qualified. He thought one world; late in life he mused that every outcome might happen. | Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference. |
| Is reality independent of observers? | Yes. He rejected the idea that observation creates reality. | Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws. |
Further reading
- Erwin Schrödinger, "The present situation in quantum mechanics" (1935), translated by John D. Trimmer in Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society (1980).
- Erwin Schrödinger, What Is Life? (1944), on the physics of heredity, which inspired Watson and Crick.
- David Deutsch, The Fabric of Reality (1997), chapter 2.
- Quantum Entanglement and Information, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.