Ulm, Bern, Berlin and Princeton, 1879–1955

Albert Einstein

Einstein helped to found quantum theory and spent the last thirty years of his life arguing that it could not be the whole truth. A physical theory, he held, must describe what is really there, whether or not anyone looks.

Two men in cloaks stand on a rocky path beside a gnarled, half-uprooted oak, looking at a thin crescent moon in an evening sky
Caspar David Friedrich, Two Men Contemplating the Moon, 1819–20. Galerie Neue Meister, Dresden. Einstein once asked a colleague whether he really believed the Moon exists only when someone looks at it.Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The view

Einstein's realism was not naive. He held that the concepts of physics are free inventions of the human mind, not read off from experience, and that a theory is judged by whether its consequences match what we observe. But he never doubted what a theory is for. It describes a real world, out there, with definite properties at definite places, whether or not anyone measures them.

Quantum mechanics, as Bohr and Heisenberg interpreted it, seemed to deny this. A particle had no definite position until it was measured; the theory gave only probabilities for the results of measurements. Einstein could accept that the theory was right about the probabilities. He could not accept that it was complete.

After Einstein, in a letter to Max Born (1926): the theory says a great deal, but it hardly brings us closer to the secret of the Old One, who does not play dice.

The argument

In 1935 Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen published the argument now called EPR. Take two particles that have interacted and flown apart, prepared so that their properties are perfectly correlated. Measure the first, and you can predict with certainty the result of the same measurement on the second, however far away it is, without disturbing it. If you can predict a property with certainty without disturbing a thing, the property must be real, an "element of reality". But quantum mechanics does not assign the second particle any definite value before the measurement. So the theory leaves out something real, and is incomplete.

The alternative, Einstein thought, was worse: that the measurement here instantly changes the reality there. He called it spooky action at a distance.

A pair of gloves is split between two boxes, and the boxes are sent to opposite ends of the Earth.

The gloves are Einstein's picture of the situation: the left glove was always in one box, and opening it only tells you what was already there. John Bell later showed that quantum particles cannot be like gloves.

Where he meets Deutsch

Deutsch shares Einstein's realism without reservation. Physics describes what exists; the Moon is there when nobody looks; and a theory that only predicts outcomes is not yet an explanation. Einstein also held on to locality, the principle that nothing acts instantaneously at a distance. Deutsch argues that Everett's theory keeps it.

Where they part

Einstein looked for the missing reality in hidden variables: definite properties, one world, with the probabilities reflecting our ignorance. Bell's theorem, and the experiments that followed, showed that no local theory of that kind can match quantum mechanics. Einstein could have local realism or one world, but not both.

Deutsch keeps both of Einstein's principles, reality and locality, and gives up the single world instead. In the multiverse, the measurement in London does not change anything in Sydney. Each observer's instances become correlated with the particle's as information spreads, no faster than light, and the correlation is settled when the two sets of records meet. Einstein's quarrel with quantum mechanics, on this account, was with the Copenhagen interpretation of it, not with the theory itself.

Einstein and Deutsch side by side
EinsteinDeutsch
What is ultimately real?Fields and their states in spacetime, existing independently of observation.Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too.
How do we know what is real?By free conjecture, tested against experience. Concepts are inventions of the mind, not abstractions from data.Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real.
One world or many?One world. He hoped a deeper theory would restore definite properties to it.Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference.
Is reality independent of observers?Yes. A real external world is the presupposition of all physics.Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws.

See every view compared →

Further reading