Washington, Princeton and the Pentagon, 1930–1982
Hugh Everett III
Hugh Everett was a graduate student when he solved the measurement problem by refusing to treat measurement as special. His thesis was cut down, mocked in Copenhagen and ignored for a decade. He left physics and never went back.
The view
Textbook quantum mechanics has two rules. Between measurements, the wave function evolves smoothly by Schrödinger's equation. At a measurement, it jumps at random to one outcome. Nobody could say what made a measurement different from any other physical interaction, since measuring devices are made of atoms too. Everett's proposal, in his Princeton thesis of 1957, was to drop the second rule entirely.
Then what happens when an observer measures a particle in a superposition? The equation says the observer becomes correlated with the particle: the whole system evolves into a superposition of "particle up, observer sees up" and "particle down, observer sees down". Each observer state is a complete, consistent observer, with memories of a definite result. Relative to each, the particle has a definite value. That is why Everett called it the relative-state formulation.
After Everett (1957): with each observation the observer state branches into a number of different states.
The argument
Everett showed that observers within the theory would see exactly what quantum mechanics predicts: definite outcomes, apparently random, with the right statistics. The appearance of collapse follows from the equation; it does not need to be added. The theory is, in a sense, the simplest possible: quantum mechanics with nothing added and nothing taken away.
Its reception was harsh. Wheeler, his supervisor, had the thesis shortened and toned down before publication, hoping to keep Bohr on side. Bohr's circle in Copenhagen dismissed it. Everett took a job in defence research, worked on the mathematics of nuclear war and later ran a consultancy. The theory was revived around 1970 by Bryce DeWitt, who gave it the name "many worlds". Everett died of a heart attack at fifty-one.
Where he meets Deutsch
This is the core of Deutsch's physics. No collapse; observers inside the theory; every outcome real. Deutsch has been the theory's most forceful advocate since the 1970s, when he heard Everett speak at a conference in Austin, Texas, and he built the theory of quantum computation on it.
Where Deutsch goes further
Everett gave the formalism. Deutsch supplies the case from explanation: the double slit and the quantum computer require something real to do the work, and the other branches are it. He also changes the picture. "Branching" suggests worlds splitting cleanly like a tree. Deutsch's multiverse is made of fungible instances, identical and uncountable as separate things, which become different only where and when information about an outcome spreads. And he and others have offered an account of probability, the hardest problem the theory faces, based on how a rational agent in a branching world should make decisions.
| Everett | Deutsch | |
|---|---|---|
| What is ultimately real? | The universal wave function, evolving deterministically, and nothing else. | Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too. |
| How do we know what is real? | By taking the formalism of quantum mechanics seriously as a description of everything, observers included. | Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real. |
| One world or many? | Many. Every outcome the equation allows occurs, each with its own observers. | Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference. |
| Is reality independent of observers? | Yes. Observers are physical systems described by the same equation as everything else. | Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws. |
Further reading
- Hugh Everett III, "'Relative state' formulation of quantum mechanics", Reviews of Modern Physics (1957).
- Peter Byrne, The Many Worlds of Hugh Everett III (2010), the biography.
- David Deutsch, The Beginning of Infinity (2011), chapter 11, "The Multiverse".
- Sean Carroll, Something Deeply Hidden (2019), a clear modern defence.
- Everett's Relative-State Formulation of Quantum Mechanics, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.