Colchester and Oxford, born 1931
Roger Penrose
Roger Penrose is a mathematician of genius who thinks quantum mechanics, as it stands, must be wrong. Somewhere between the atom and the cat, he argues, gravity steps in and forces the world to choose.
The view
Penrose shared the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics for showing that black holes are a robust prediction of general relativity. His work spans geometry, cosmology and the tilings that bear his name. On the foundations of quantum mechanics he has a definite and unusual position: the theory is incomplete, and the missing piece is gravity.
A superposition of a particle in two places is also, by general relativity, a superposition of two slightly different geometries of spacetime. Penrose argues that such a superposition is unstable, and that it decays into one geometry or the other in a time that depends on how different they are. For an electron the time is enormous, so superpositions survive; for a cat it is unimaginably short. Collapse is real, objective, and caused by physics, not by observers.
After Penrose: the more mass is displaced between the two alternatives, the sooner nature chooses between them.
The argument
Penrose is also a mathematical Platonist. Mathematical truths exist in a timeless realm, and mathematicians perceive them. In The Emperor's New Mind (1989) he argued from Gödel's incompleteness theorem that human mathematical insight cannot be captured by any algorithm, and so that the mind cannot be a computer. Something non-computable must be going on in the brain, and he proposed that it lies in the physics of objective collapse.
The figure is schematic: the timescales are orders of magnitude in Penrose's proposal, not measurements. Experiments are now under way that put ever larger objects into superposition; if one survives longer than Penrose's estimate allows, his theory is refuted.
Where he meets Deutsch
Both are realists: there is a fact about what happens in the box, whatever anyone knows. Both think the abstract world of mathematics is real and independent of us. And Penrose's theory is testable, which Deutsch admires: it makes a prediction that standard quantum mechanics does not, so experiment can decide.
Where they part
Penrose adds a new physical process to explain away the branches; Deutsch thinks the branches need no explaining away. So far every experiment has confirmed unmodified quantum mechanics, and every quantum computer built is, on Deutsch's reading, running on the multiverse that Penrose's collapse would destroy at large scales.
They part even more sharply on minds. Deutsch holds that the laws of physics allow a universal computer to simulate any physical system, the brain included, and so that minds are computations. Penrose's Gödelian argument, Deutsch replies, assumes that mathematicians know their own reasoning to be sound, which no fallible thinker can know. And Deutsch's Platonism is not Penrose's: mathematical truths are real, but our access to them is through physical proofs, not a special perception.
| Penrose | Deutsch | |
|---|---|---|
| What is ultimately real? | Three worlds: the physical, the mental and the Platonic world of mathematics, each emerging from another. | Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too. |
| How do we know what is real? | By mathematical insight, which he argues goes beyond any computation, and by experiment. | Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real. |
| One world or many? | One world. Superpositions of large enough objects collapse objectively. | Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference. |
| Is reality independent of observers? | Yes. Collapse is a physical process, with or without an observer. | Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws. |
Further reading
- Roger Penrose, The Emperor's New Mind (1989).
- Roger Penrose, The Road to Reality (2004), chapters 29 and 30 on quantum measurement and gravity.
- Roger Penrose, "On gravity's role in quantum state reduction", General Relativity and Gravitation (1996).
- David Deutsch, The Fabric of Reality (1997), chapter 10, on mathematics and proof.