Princeton and Austin, 1911–2008

John Archibald Wheeler

Wheeler supervised Everett's thesis, named the black hole and taught a generation of physicists. In later life he came to think that reality is built from the answers to yes-or-no questions, and that observers take part in building it.

A circular and square arrangement of the sixty-four hexagrams of the I Ching, each made of broken and unbroken lines, with handwritten numbers added
The sixty-four hexagrams of the I Ching, sent to Leibniz by the Jesuit Joachim Bouvet in 1701, with Leibniz's binary numbers added. Every pattern built from yes-or-no lines: it from bit, three centuries early.Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The view

Wheeler's career ran through every stage of twentieth-century physics. He worked with Bohr on the theory of nuclear fission in 1939, helped revive general relativity in the 1950s, and popularised the term "black hole". He was also Hugh Everett's doctoral supervisor, and for a time Everett's advocate, before he distanced himself from the many-worlds reading.

His own late philosophy went in another direction. In a paper of 1989 he proposed "it from bit": every particle, every field, even spacetime itself, derives its existence from the answers to yes-or-no questions, binary choices registered by apparatus. Reality, at bottom, is information.

After Wheeler: no elementary phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is a registered, observed phenomenon.

The argument

Wheeler's favourite illustration was a parlour game. In twenty questions, one player leaves the room while the others choose a word, then comes back and asks yes-or-no questions to find it. In Wheeler's version the others secretly agree not to choose a word at all. Each answers as they like, as long as the answer is consistent with every answer given so far. The questions still narrow down to a word, but the word did not exist until the questions were asked. Which questions the questioner chose shaped which word emerged.

His delayed-choice experiment pushed the point further. Whether a photon in an interferometer is recorded as having taken one path or both can be decided after it has passed the first beam splitter. Wheeler concluded that observers take part, in a strange sense, in bringing about the past.

No word has been chosen. Ask questions; the answers will stay consistent.

Wheeler's surprise version of twenty questions. Each answer is chosen at random from those consistent with what has already been said.

Where he meets Deutsch

Wheeler saw that information is physical and fundamental, and that quantum theory and the theory of computation belong together. Deutsch's universal quantum computer and constructor theory's treatment of information as a physical quantity are in that line. Wheeler also encouraged Everett when nobody else would, and his early endorsement helped the thesis into print.

Where they part

Wheeler kept the observer at the centre, where Bohr had put it. Deutsch and Everett take it out. In the multiverse there are no special acts of registration, only physical interactions, some of which make records. A delayed-choice experiment does not reach into the past. The photon's instances took both paths, as they always do, and the later choice determines only which records end up correlated with which.

And the twenty questions game, charming as it is, has a hidden player: the rule that answers must be consistent. Consistency is a fact about the world, not a decision of the players. That is where Deutsch would locate reality: in what constrains the answers, not in the asking.

Wheeler and Deutsch side by side
WheelerDeutsch
What is ultimately real?Information. Every physical thing derives its existence from the answers to yes-or-no questions.Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too.
How do we know what is real?By acts of observation, which are also acts of participation.Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real.
One world or many?Qualified. He supported Everett's thesis, then withdrew his support.Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference.
Is reality independent of observers?Qualified. No phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is an observed phenomenon.Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws.

See every view compared →

Further reading