Verona, Marseille and London, Ontario, born 1956
Carlo Rovelli
Carlo Rovelli proposes that quantum mechanics is not about things but about relations. A property is never simply had; it is had relative to some other system. The world is a web of interactions, and there is no view from nowhere.
The view
Rovelli is a founder of loop quantum gravity and the author of popular books on time and physics; the time site discusses his view of time. In 1996 he proposed a reading of quantum mechanics that takes one lesson of relativity further. In relativity, velocity has no meaning except relative to something else. Rovelli suggests that in quantum mechanics every property is like that.
When two systems interact, a fact is established relative to each of them. An electron has a definite spin relative to the apparatus that measured it. Relative to a third system that has not interacted with either, there is no such fact, and the third system is right to describe the electron and apparatus together as a superposition. Neither description is the true one. There is no true one.
After Rovelli: the world is not a collection of things but of events, and properties exist only in interactions.
The argument
The standard puzzle is the one called Wigner's friend. A friend in a sealed laboratory measures a particle and sees a definite result. Wigner, outside, describes the whole laboratory as a superposition until he opens the door. Who is right? Rovelli says both. The result exists relative to the friend; relative to Wigner, it does not yet. Facts are perspectival, as in the mirror in van Eyck's room.
Where he meets Deutsch
Rovelli rejects collapse and rejects any special role for conscious observers: any physical system can play the part of an observer. He also emphasises information and interaction, which fits Deutsch's account of how the differences between branches spread only through local interactions.
Where they part
Deutsch's realism wants one objective account of what exists, and Everett supplies it: the multiverse, with all its branches, is the same from every perspective. Wigner and the friend do not hold different facts. Wigner's description, a superposition of two friends, is simply a description of the larger reality that contains both the friend who saw up and the friend who saw down.
Without such an account, Deutsch would argue, relative facts explain nothing. If a fact relative to me and a fact relative to you can disagree, what makes them agree whenever we compare notes? Everett answers that question; relational quantum mechanics has to add rules to make it come out right.
| Rovelli | Deutsch | |
|---|---|---|
| What is ultimately real? | Events: interactions between systems, and the relative facts they establish. | Whatever our best explanations refer to: the multiverse, and emergent and abstract things too. |
| How do we know what is real? | By physics, which describes how systems affect one another, not how things are absolutely. | Conjecture and criticism. If our best explanation needs it, it exists: if it kicks back, it is real. |
| One world or many? | Qualified. One world, but no single, absolute account of it. | Many. Our universe is one layer of a multiverse, revealed by quantum interference. |
| Is reality independent of observers? | Qualified. No observers are special, but facts are relative to systems. | Yes. Observers are physical systems inside reality, governed by the same laws. |
Further reading
- Carlo Rovelli, "Relational quantum mechanics", International Journal of Theoretical Physics (1996).
- Carlo Rovelli, Helgoland (2021), the view for a general reader.
- Relational Quantum Mechanics, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.